Saturday, 31 March 2007

Tension growing between Britain and Iran?


The British sailors and marines held captive were shown on Iran television. The British Government condemned this as “the sailors being paraded on television”. The Iranians said the tape, showing the prisoners eating, was released to reassure their families that they are being well looked after.

I want to see a jingoistic free account and analyses of events. But once again the British press appear to be acting as the willing tool of Government propaganda. They shout “Is the Government doing enough to free our troops? “.

I am yet to see a forensic examination of the facts as stated by Britain and Iran. What do we know?

The Ministry of Defence says:
  • At 07:39 hrs on 23 March 2007 a merchant ship located 1.7 nautical miles (3.1km) inside Iraqi territorial waters was boarded by crew from HMS Cornwall. The operation was observed by Cornwall’s Lynx helicopter.
  • Communication with the boarding party was lost at 09:10
  • The Lynx returned to the scene and reported the two boats were being escorted by Iranian Navy vessels toward the Shatt al Arab waterway
  • The British state the Iranians first claimed the incident occurred at a location within Iraq waters, but corrected this to a position 1 nautical mile (1.9km) from its first position and within Iranian waters.

While the British Government is ignoring the fact, it must be noted while reference is made to distances from the boarder; agreement has never been reached between Iran and Iraq on the position of the boarder. Making definitive statements and basing a case on a location 1.7 nautical miles from a disputed and undefined boarder doesn’t stand-up to close scrutiny. A fact identified by Russia at the UN Security Council discussions on Thursday.

From known facts, it is obvious the boarding of the merchant vessel was ineptly planned and executed:
  • Why didn’t HMS Cornwall see the approach of the Iranian boats on its radar?
  • Why did the Lynx helicopter have insufficient fuel to remain on patrol? (The Lynx had returned to Cornwall for refuelling, at the time the Iranians captured the sailors).
  • Why was there a failure in the communication system between Cornwall and the two patrol boats?

In an attempt to get an alternative prospective, yesterday I looked at the following Middle East news organisations:

Bahrain Tribune - no reference to the story
The Daily Star (Lebanon) - ditto

Middle East Times (Egypt) - a report that Iran says Britain exploited UN; and second sailor ‘confesses’.

Gulf News Online (UAE) - nothing in the headlines, but at the bottom of the page a link to an Iranian statement why the release of the woman captive has been put off

Arab News (The Middle East’s Leading English Language Daily) (Saudi Arabia) - At the end of a long report of a news conference given at the end of the Arab Summit at Riyadh, quote:

Asked about the Kingdom’s stance on the 15 British soldiers who are withheld with Iranian officials, Prince Saudi described it as “unfortunate.”
“We do not need any things to add to the already inflammatory situation in the region,” he said. He said he extended his heart out to the families of the captured British sailors

Islamic Republic News Agency (Iran) - reported on a telephone conversation between President Mahout Ahmadinejad and the Turkish Prime Minister, quote:
During the telephone conversation, Ahmadinejad underlined that the British troopers have for many times in the past violated international rules and conventions and illegally crossed into Iranian borders.
Despite their official commitment to avoid repetition of such illegal crossing into Iranian land and territorial water, the Britons have resorted to fabricated hue and cry instead of apology for their action and of helping resolve the issue through diplomatic channels, he said.
The Turkish premier, for his part, called Britain's threats for freezing ties with Iran as a "mistake" and urged the Iranian officials to permit Turkish ambassador to Tehran to meet the captured British sailors in an effort to foil the ongoing false propaganda.

In a separate report on the telephone conversation between the Iranian and Australian Foreign Ministers to discuss the arrest of the British sailors, quote:

The Iranian foreign minister hoped that the British officials will avoid the hue and cries launched by the media, which will make the issue more complicated.
"Iran welcomes pursuance of the issue by Australia if it can help Britain to act reasonably," he added.

Clearly in the Middle East the affair is seen as a low priority event. Even in Iran they are trying to cool the situation. Perhaps its time for the British to keep “Macho man” Blair off the TV and apply some quiet diplomacy. As for the British press, as can be seen from today’s copy of the Sun, it’s starting to lose interest.

22 comments:

Shrink wrapped scream said...

I am so glad to find another loud (and more elequent) voice than mine, who is outraged enough to have the temerity to question the sanitised version of what the hell is going on in Iraq/Iran.. good on you, chuck - couldn't agree more!

YesBut said...

Hi Carol
One day we will be told the truth. But by that time hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqis will have died and a country destroyed. In the mean time Blair & Bush will be living in blissful retirement.
YB

Daughter of a RN sailor said...

Watery borders are never precise, which is why there is a 5 mile "give and take" zone around each one. So even if we were a mile or two over the border, our personnel shouldn't have been taken. We were operating in the region under a UN mandate i.e. checking ships were carrying only the cargo they declared, and not taking weapons to Iraq to support the "insurgents". The most Iraq should have done is tell us that they believe we're in their territory and tell us to move.

They should release the personnel now. They think we trespassed on their side of the border, point taken, now hand them back. The accusations of spying are ridiculous. They knew about the UN mandate. We, and others, have operated in that stretch of water for years.

As for Bush and Blair. Oh dear God....
When Bush got up on TV yesterday and started asking for the 'British Hostages' back (We never called them that!) I thought, that's right, make it worse why don't you.
The pair of them need their heads knocked together. But then Blair has always fancied himself as a president, not a PM. So not surprising that he enjoys all the macho posturing.

I heard a report the other day that the USA was sending another ship into the region, one with 'nuclear capabilities'. But I've heard nothing since-????
Time to kiss our butts goodbye. (no wonder he isn't worried about climate change. We aint gonna be here much longer...)

YesBut said...

Hi daughter of an rn sailor.
Do you blog?
If so please leave your URL, because I really like your opinions and style.
YB

Anonymous said...

says the majority of people payback his or her borrowing products when they're due and also lacking fines
A number one consumer debt aid organization should expect the number of individuals looking towards these folks with regard to guide more than fast cash advance financial obligations to help double this unique. arrears nonprofit charities reveals near have used that temporarily, big desire fiscal loans 2010. This nonprofit charities affirms four years gone by the number of buyers using them seemed to be simple.
szybka gotówka bez bik
najlepsza pożyczka gotówkowa 2010
kredyt gotówkowy bez zaświadczeń o zarobkach
wyświetl
pożyczki bez bik dobra pożyczka

http://pozyczki-prwatne.com.pl
http://szybkapozyczkaonline.com.pl
http://kredyty-bez-bik.org.pl

Anonymous said...

Instead of credit card consolidation loans some people simply transfer their balance to a
different lender. They will not necessarily be the right solution for you
is to opt for the unsecured option.

Also visit my web site - best consolidation loans

Anonymous said...

Do the same thing for the outer edge of your eyebrows.
Reunions that you get if you hear that your
ex Can T Get a girlfriend, it's an extremely upsetting experience to have broken up with your Can T Get A Girlfriend. You never know when you may have done wrong when you get together with old friends and hang up with them, so don't start
sending flowers and stopping by every night. Try the following in order to make any woman highly excited about them.
He tells girls they look fat in those pants?

Anonymous said...

Αndy Iliaѕ іs a сo-ωriter for Τo gеt moгe fun and enjoуable office Christmаs ρaгty games іdеаs,
you can find a great list. They went bacκ to
the waterfall and collecteԁ theіг thіngs, readу to go hοme.

Some оf these аre viԁeo games baѕed arounԁ ωinteг themes, plaуаble online through a user's web browser. This kind of board game can take you back in time and enhance the knowledge of history. You can get many options and ideas of organizing the party online.

My page :: fun math games free online

Anonymous said...

Тhis іnfοrmation is priceless. Whеre cаn I find out more?


Αlso vіѕit my weblog :: 3d tattoos pictures

Anonymous said...

This іs really intеrestіng, Yοu're a very skilled blogger. I've joineԁ your
rsѕ fеed аnd look fοrwaгԁ tо ѕeekіng morе of your eхcellent
post. Also, Ӏ've shared your website in my social networks!

my webpage carpet cleaning phoenix

Anonymous said...

Ηeya i am foг the pгimary time hеre.
Ι came acroѕs this board and I to find It reallу useful & it helped me out muсh.

I hope to prοvide one thing bаck аnd help others such as you aiԁed me.


Feel free to vіsit my ωeb page ... www.firstusacarpetcleaning.com

Anonymous said...

Once you get through, you will walk away with somehting completely different to what you wanted!
Media such as internet, magazines, and cover fashion shows in some cases?
Here we are going to be in the range of $46. They're too scared to do it by hand even. Last year, on more than one occasion, high profile celebrities such as Kim Kardashian and the Duchess of Cambridge, aka Kate Middleton, showed off her ability to make multiple style statements during a single day.

My weblog - Ao so mi nam

Anonymous said...

But still if you do not set yοuг serѵer time to PST, you should ѕee a
list of iOЅ рhoto apps hеrе.
The competition of thе tech gіants onlу brings new innovationѕ to the tablet fοrmat ωіthout compromising qualіtу.

From Yаhoo AnѕwerWhen it сomеѕ
to technology thеy uѕe іn the statеs.
As prеdіcted, some folks ωerе
ԁisаρρointeԁ bу thе iPаd mini anԁ fourth generation iPad wіll be 9.

Νeveгthеless, іt alгeaԁу hаs
content providers lineԁ up for the Retinа ԁіsplay, of сouгѕe, on youг buԁget.


Look into mу page - may tinh bang

Anonymous said...

When you suggest a time and place to get a how to attract younger women this will
help you to be happy. Adventurous: Men who take chances and try new things are very sexy to women.
Knowing that you took time out of your way and that
is usually why how to attract younger women they
give up on her. This can be hard, but it's not enough for you and your how to attract younger women.

Take a look at my web-site :: attract women

Anonymous said...

You can enlarge your penis size then you are gravely
mistaken. The good thing is, most men approach getting a
how do you get a girlfriend will become simple.
Remember, you're not going to dig the idea of getting back together with one another. Today s bad boys come from all walks of life say to their how do you get A girlfriend or the woman you are keen on.

Anonymous said...

Tips on how to get a Attract Women, because to think that you are unaffected,
by saying for instance" You are in a hurry to reconcile with her.

Also visit my web-site :: how to attract beautiful women

Anonymous said...

This page certainly has all the info I wanted about this subject and didn't know who to ask.

my web blog - http://Sai.unisoftinformatics.com/groups/an-update-On-necessary-details-of-Seo-training/

Anonymous said...

Heya! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems
with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing months of hard work due to no
data backup. Do you have any solutions to prevent hackers?


Feel free to surf to my page; games unblocked

Anonymous said...

Hello i am kavin, its my first occasion to commenting anywhere, when
i read this piece of writing i thought i could also make comment due to this good post.


Feel free to visit my blog seo marketing training

Anonymous said...

Hello There. I found your weblog the usage of msn. That is an extremely neatly written article.
I will make sure to bookmark it and return
to read extra of your helpful information. Thank you for the post.
I will certainly comeback.

my web-site ... unblocked zombie games

Anonymous said...

Everything is very open with a precise description of the issues.
It was truly informative. Your site is very helpful.
Many thanks for sharing!

Have a look at my web blog plumbers world

Anonymous said...

Otherwise, you might limit mafia wars on the kitchen or laundry
room and stay creative concerning how to support the melting ice.
You is going to be challenged from the animated characters that are included with laughter and
adventure. Write along the titles of well know Christmas carols and hang the
titles in the box preferably a Christmas gift box. Most often Anniversary party
guests will love playing a mixture of games or printable
activities which can be interactive. For sure, should you include these games
within your friend's hen event she would definitely appreciate it and appreciates anything you'd prepared for her.


Here is my site - fun unblocked games at school